Strange way to judge talent
by Grainne
Now in the grand scheme of things it’s not a huge issue but a minor, well actually more than minor irritation. What’s irking me? The format of RTE’s latest talent show ‘The Voice of Ireland’, that’s what.
The first part was ok, the initial selection of contenders to go forward. In fact it was a good idea to have the panel of judges keep their backs to the performers so that their looks and appearance didn’t impinge on their consciousness and they were being judged solely on their singing ability.
Now that the judges have selected their entrants however the show has moved on to a nonsensical and ill-judged format for whittling down the numbers. Who on earth dreamt up the notion that they should be paired? Pitting individuals who entered as sole performers with fellow contestants? It cannot work on any level and clearly isn’t. So much so that it’s downright unfair to the contestants. But then the feelings and sensibilities of contestants appears to be the least consideration of the makers who want only entertainment value to maximise audiences.
Last week saw a couple of very disappointed contestants go home in tears. It was little consolation for them to be lavished with praise for their performances by the judges but then, when it came down to it and a choice had to be made, they were the ones ousted, whereas they could well have qualified for the next stage if they’d been judged on their individual performance.
There’s also the issue of song selection from the coaches. Brian Kennedy’s choice of ‘Dirty Old Town’ is a case in point. It’s one of those sing-along pub come-all-yas that requires no vocal talent and was a waste of the two he chose to perform it. Their disappointment was evident. They made a valiant effort, to be fair to them but it wasn’t a proper test of their singing voices. I can understand the thinking behind giving contestants different songs to sing to test and stretch their abilities but not with that song like that.
Who will win a singing talent competition run in such an unorthodox manner? Not the best singer in any event.









After my parents died my youngest brother and my aunt joined us for a couple of Christmases.